Alfa Romeo Forum banner

wheel bolt snapped in hub

3.6K views 29 replies 13 participants last post by  jim hazell  
#1 ·
Have just rotated the wheels on p1 916 Spider and noticed that one of the bolts on front hub has snapped flush with hub. :( Have spent last hr confusing myself with extraction tools and am unsure what i need to buy?

Anyone had similar experience and what was your solution ? :)
 
#8 ·
Thanks Mike, i did look at screw extractors and Easy Outs seem only available in States while ebay seems full of cheap China kits that are not hardened and will with my luck snap.

If you know of a good kit in UK then please point me in the right direction as i am asking for pointers on which specific kit to go for.
 
#9 · (Edited)
Hi EauRouge

Before investing in bolt extractors try this method.
If the bolt looks 'corroded in' spray the area of the bolt thread liberally with PlusGas and allow it to do its job. Then use the centre punch, not in the centre of the bolt, but towards the outer edge and tap the broken bolt out in a counter clockwise (CCW) direction. When the bolt is out far enough grip it with mole grips to speed up removal.
If you fail to remove it with this method then use the bolt extractors.

Phil

PS. Forgot to say that PlusGas is a 'must have essential' for working on cars.
 
#14 ·
Thanks guys, have just soaked in +Gas and noticed that the thread at rear is rusted as AlfaFamily said it would be. Therefore ill buy a couple of new drill bits tomorrow and see if they are able to wind it through the hub and extract from rear, if that fails to work then I'll attempt extraction approach as i have just tried P3rsky's punch approach with no joy. :(
 
#17 · (Edited)
Another way if you have a decent set of drill bits and a reversible drill..
good dose of plus gas.. leave for 24 hours..
find the center.. drill a pilot hole .. use progressively bigger drills , Don't go all the way through.. about half way..
when you are up to about 75% of the bolt diameter ..every now and then give the drill a shot in reverse ..angle the drill a tad to make it seize..
the drilling friction heat combined with reverse, anti clockwise turning will spin it out.

There are even reverse.. left hand.. drill bits for this purpose.. but I find a normal clockwise drill bit usually works..

As you say..If it's clear at the back.. just clockwise drilling may work..
I use easy out extractors as a last resort.. if it snaps off.. you're buggered.
try not to smack it too much with a chisel or center pop.. it can distort the bolt and make it tighter..
I'd be looking to see what caused it in the first place.. torque wrench good ?? do you have spacers fitted??


www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYuaPBX1sT4

you tube says video not available .. strange .. anyway just google "left hand drill bit".. it's on there..
 
#18 ·
Thanks Seadart for the advice, no spacers fitted but! i know the advice is to not use copper-slip on wheel bolts yet this was the only bolt without it applied.

Had another crack at it just now after having it soaked in +Gas with P3rsky's method after snapping another drill bit, HSS metal bit which i found to be useless - 10mins drilling and a small creator and a broken drill bit!

Anyway, noticed i had generated some heat in the bolt so grabbed the punch and hammer and one whack and it moved. :) Few more blows and enough showing for mole-grips and bob is now my uncle.

Thanks guys for the tips, and cheers Phil/P3rsky 2nd attempt and it worked a treat. :)
 
#24 ·
It depends on how the bolts are rated. You'll often find that the torque range equates to 80% to 100% of the failure point ( 101% = shearing begins but the fastener doesn't necessarily fail ).

I think it would be unlikely that wheel bolts would be specified like that owing to the tendency for tyre fitters to consider not sheared = not tight enough :) and that they typically do not use torque wrenches or, if they do, to only ever set it to one value* and never calibrate it.


* In my experience, where tyre fitters use a torque wrench, they never set it beforehand so must have it set to some generic value.
 
#25 ·
In my experience it is best to never let tyre fitters near a car - just wheels, loose and even then they require strict observation/monitoring as in "please don't damage these wheels"
Those who do the same job day in day out often become lazy and standards inevitably slip - taxi drivers......
 
#26 ·
Its been mentioned, but 140Nm is way too tight.

I do mine to 100Nm on the Spider.