Alfa Romeo Forum banner

1 - 20 of 26 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,233 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Esteemed dudes of the Great AOracle.

Bought my old ma' a TV since her old flat screen CRT recently demised.

She has a Freesat box so a dish and a screw-in "F-type" (??) co-ax cable.

I bought an HD TV since for the price, I think this is one useful feature for her (the Elder Mrs S. does not "need" 3D or Smart or any other features, for example).

Now then.. TV has a built in Freeview HD tuner, so it needs an aerial (push-in) co-ax cable, which we have established she doesn't have.

So .. for the time being I plugged her Freesat box to the TV using her SCART cable (replicating her existing setup) but SCART as any fule knoe .. (I do now.. :D ) is only 720 definitions and not 1080. Her freesat box doesn't have an HDMI out.. just SCART so it'll never be able to pass on "HD".

Ideally and in the perfect world.. I need an adaptor/connector co-ax.. that converts screw-type co-ax cable to a push in... but it seems beyond the wit of Panashinang electronic$ corporations to invent this 99p device.

My options are:

1) Re-fit (!) an aerial and then plug that in to the Freeview-HD enabled TV
2) Buy a Freeview HD box and use an HDMI cable to connect to the TV (saves having an aerial but introduces an extra and unnecessary piece of kit in the shape of the Freeview HD box). TV already has the doodah built in.

Anyone knoe any other options, using the existing kit?

I'd prefer it if my old ma' only has one appliance and one remote to worry aboot option 1 would appear favourite, as I see it... but she has a pretty new and decent satellite dish already so it's a pity to dump it and/or go to further expense if it's avoidable..?


Ta.

Ralf S.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
534 Posts
Why not get a Freesat HD box with HDMI to replace the existing SCART one?
 
R

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
Ref option 2 do you mean Free sat HD box ?

A Free view one will still require an aerial.

Assuming yes I'd go option 2 to save too much bother. A freesat hd box can be picked up from £50 upwards and for not more than £100 you're looking boxes with recorders. It's going to cost you more than that to buy and install a decent high gain aerial suitable for Freeview HD.

I hear your concern ref the single set of buttons but being linked by hdmi the freesat box will automatically switch the tv to the right input and its more likely than not its buttons will control the volume and power on/off too unless it is a real cheapy.

Lastly even if such a connector could be found you'll not be able to convert a signal from a satellite dish into something which a tv can decode via its RF input I'm afraid.




Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,780 Posts
Amazon.co.uk: f to coax adapter

Probably won't work, though - I don't think a satellite dish will make a very effective UHF antenna!

How strong is the terrestrial signal where she lives? A set-top antenna may be the cheapest solution if there's a good signal.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
52 Posts
As above F to co-ax adaptors do exist, however just putting one of those onto the cable and plugging it into the TV still won't get you a Freeview picture. Your options for HD are

1 Buy a Freeview HD box. If you get a recorder you'll ideally want a second feed for the dish.
2 Fit a terrestrial aerial. In terms of ease of use this is easiest.

I hope this helps.

Oh, and SCART doesn't even carry 720 line definition, just bog standard 576 standard definition. Of course the other question is does your mother really want HD? If she's perfectly happy with SD then why not leave it at that. Easiest and cheapest solution.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,233 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Why not get a Freesat HD box with HDMI to replace the existing SCART one?
That's probably the favourite option.. since it doesn't need an aerial. I was just curious if there was an option I didn't know aboot.. :)

Unfortunately I remembered my mum's Freesat box was a Freeview box... Should visit her more often I suppose.. :D

Ralf S.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,233 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
Ref option 2 do you mean Free sat HD box ?
Aye!

I get confused when I'm writing it.. I had no chance when buying it.. :D

Assuming yes I'd go option 2 to save too much bother. A freesat hd box can be picked up from £50 upwards and for not more than £100 you're looking boxes with recorders. It's going to cost you more than that to buy and install a decent high gain aerial suitable for Freeview HD.

I hear your concern ref the single set of buttons but being linked by hdmi the freesat box will automatically switch the tv to the right input and its more likely than not its buttons will control the volume and power on/off too unless it is a real cheapy.
Yes. Agreed. :thumbs:


Ralf S.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,780 Posts
Unfortunately I remembered my mum's Freesat box was a Freeview box... Should visit her more often I suppose.. :D

Ralf S
If it's a Freeview box it must have been getting a UHF signal from somewhere, so whatever's connected to the input to that will work if connected to the new TV. Seems odd that it's an F type connector - try changing it to a push-in coax & see if it works.

(You don't need to use an adaptor, just get a coax connector & swap it for the one on the cable)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
52 Posts
A SCART to HDMI converter is useful if you don't have a SCART socket available, but it won't give you HD. It might have an upscaler built in which will artificially convert a 576 line signal to either 720 or 1080, but the TV will do this anyway.

Also, as the recommended converter in that advert is £50, you might as well buy the Manhattan Plaza S2 Freesat HD box for the same money http://www.johnlewis.com/manhattan-plaza-hd-s2-smart-freesat-hd-digital-receiver/p631121?kpid=232294305&s_kenid=44ee18d4-3b63-b149-b2ec-0000472f68ba&s_kwcid=ppc_pla&tmad=c&tmcampid=73 and have true HD.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,233 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
If it's a Freeview box it must have been getting a UHF signal from somewhere, so whatever's connected to the input to that will work if connected to the new TV. Seems odd that it's an F type connector - try changing it to a push-in coax & see if it works.

(You don't need to use an adaptor, just get a coax connector & swap it for the one on the cable)
She has a FreeSAT box... getting its signal from a dish with an F-type connector on the end.

To be honest, I thought dish or aerial didn't matter.. and that it was just a case of getting the right connector on the end of teh cable... but dish seems to only lead to F-type and aerial seems to only lead to push-in coax's... and the two don't seem to be interchangeable.

If it was technically possible, I'd stick a push-in plug on the end of the (sat) cable, instead of the F-type connector that's there now..


Ralf S.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
38,319 Posts
You can just swap the connector on the co-ax cable.

But you still need a TV antenna on the other end, not a parabolic dish.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
13,233 Posts
Discussion Starter #18
Also, as the recommended converter in that advert is £50, you might as well buy the Manhattan Plaza S2 Freesat HD box for the same money Buy Manhattan Plaza HD-S2 Smart freesat HD Digital Receiver online at John Lewis and have true HD.
Good link.. ta. :thumbs:

I'll probably go this route. She has a non-HD Manhattan box at the moment and she knows how to work that. The remote control looks identical. :D

I suppose it means that I didn't strictly need to buy a TV with a FreeviewHD tuner built in... but not sure that's a total disaster. :D


Ralf S.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
534 Posts
Today's dumb question

If your mum has a freeview box that connects to the old TV, how did the signal get to the freeview box?

Maybe its a simple case of taking the ariel out of the freeview box and connecting it direct to the TV
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,860 Posts
Today's dumb question

If your mum has a freeview box that connects to the old TV, how did the signal get to the freeview box?

Maybe its a simple case of taking the ariel out of the freeview box and connecting it direct to the TV
No....she has a freesat box...not freeview.

However,and i may be wrong...surely the freesat was only giving her SD quality through the scart lead in the first place....i know you've bought her a nice HD receiving TV but would she really notice the difference in quality ?

I know my mum wouldn't notice if she was watching through thick fog !!! :lol:

Sometimes i try to help her with technology and she doesn't really give a toss :rolleyes:
 
1 - 20 of 26 Posts
Top