Alfa Romeo Forum banner

1 - 20 of 23 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
37,997 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
On the 25th September 2010 I took out insurance on the Puma, the annual premium was £300 give or take a few pence for TPFT

Today I asked AF about swapping the insurance to my new car (BMW 528i SE). AF said that the annual premium for that car is £570 so to change over I have been quoted £223.04 until September 25th 2011

Here is the rub. Yesterday I went to an insurance comparison website, just to get a rough idea of what an annual premium on the new car should be.

The Cheapest Quote came in at £370 TPFT (compared to around £300 for the Puma)

Due to the Difference in price to change at AF and the cost of a new premium elsewhere, I decided to enquire about cancelling my policy and getting a refund for the remaining cover.

The amount that I am entitled to as a refund was £43
So Three months insurance would have cost me £257 :mad:
(Surely £300 divided by 12 x 3 should be £75, plus an admin charge??)


Therefore I am now either stuck with paying the £223 to change, or taking out a new policy elsewhere for £370 and getting a Paltry £43 back from my current policy which I think is absolutely disgusting.

They have effectively locked me into paying over the odds to change over my vehicle.

I have used AF a few times in the past, but when this year’s policy runs out I can say for sure that they will not be getting my business, even if I have to pay slightly more elsewhere.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37,997 Posts
Discussion Starter #2
Just found a site quoting £329 per annum for the Beemer. So providing I can get a FAIR price back for the remainder of my cover I shall be going elsewhere immediately.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,897 Posts
It drives you mental car insurance.....wind direction springs tae mind.

A while back parking in a driveway reduced your premium as it was considered less a risk..no one should crash into it.

NOW..if the bit in gthe paper is to be believed.

Insurance reduced if you leave your car in the street.....the reason..if its in yer drive..they break into your house to get the keys and steal the car...so if you park in yer drive it costs you more.

mah insurance is due soon...anyone know the prime criteria to reduce your insurance as leaving the car on the road is easy to do to save a few bob.

Pomeo
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,191 Posts
sadly not, the amount you are refunded is reduced on a sliding scale, so if for example you cancel after one month, you may get 90% of your premium back, if you cancel after 6 months, rather than getting 50% back it may only be 30%

so if you pay 600 per year, and have 3 months left to run, you wont get the full £150 back...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37,997 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
To be honest I wasn't expecting to get the 75% back that I still have to run, but being offered 14% back for 75% of a years insurance takes the **** IMO.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,897 Posts
To be honest I wasn't expecting to get the 75% back that I still have to run, but being offered 14% back for 75% of a years insurance takes the **** IMO.
fraid they have got away with that for years....easier to let it run and jump ship on renewal.

As guid and as much use as the FSCS.

Pomeo
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37,997 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
In the past from other insurers I have always had a fair amount back, minus an admin charge of course which I would accept.

This time though, it seems to have changed and ripping-off at every opportunity seems the norm. :(
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
595 Posts
give them a call and ask them to change it over to the beemer on the cheaper quote offered online by another company (be honest and tell them the exact price and company that quoted it), some will use their common sense and match it, because their only going to lose your business if they don't which doesn't help them in the long term.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37,997 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
I tried that ands they couldn't do it. To be honest I am pretty sure they know they have got me stuck.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,897 Posts
I tried that ands they couldn't do it. To be honest I am pretty sure they know they have got me stuck.
alrighty...change insurance to a pedal cycle get refund and then go.

Pomeo
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37,997 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
alrighty...change insurance to a pedal cycle get refund and then go.

Pomeo
I tried that with them before.

I changed from my 156 (Group 14) to my Puma (Group 12) and they kindly told me there was no charge.

I reckon to change to a pedal cycle there would be no charge as well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
595 Posts
Try having a word with someone in Citizens Advice:
Citizens Advice  - the charity for your community
or/and Consumer Direct:
Consumer Direct
because it does seem overly excessive, like mentioned above, they normally charge an admin fee of £50ish but their taking the ****!

Failing that, find out how much it would be to upgrade on the puma to fully comp (providing this allow's you to drive other cars on a third party basis), if it's cheap enough do that and register the BMW in your g/f name or your dad's etc.
 

·
AO Traders
Joined
·
592 Posts
On the 25th September 2010 I took out insurance on the Puma, the annual premium was £300 give or take a few pence for TPFT

Today I asked AF about swapping the insurance to my new car (BMW 528i SE). AF said that the annual premium for that car is £570 so to change over I have been quoted £223.04 until September 25th 2011

Here is the rub. Yesterday I went to an insurance comparison website, just to get a rough idea of what an annual premium on the new car should be.

The Cheapest Quote came in at £370 TPFT (compared to around £300 for the Puma)

Due to the Difference in price to change at AF and the cost of a new premium elsewhere, I decided to enquire about cancelling my policy and getting a refund for the remaining cover.

The amount that I am entitled to as a refund was £43
So Three months insurance would have cost me £257 :mad:
(Surely £300 divided by 12 x 3 should be £75, plus an admin charge??)


Therefore I am now either stuck with paying the £223 to change, or taking out a new policy elsewhere for £370 and getting a Paltry £43 back from my current policy which I think is absolutely disgusting.

They have effectively locked me into paying over the odds to change over my vehicle.

I have used AF a few times in the past, but when this year’s policy runs out I can say for sure that they will not be getting my business, even if I have to pay slightly more elsewhere.
Hiya,

Please feel free to PM me your policy number and a contact telephone number and I will look into this for you.

Thanks
Dan
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
277 Posts
Not going to criticise insurance companies but the differential in premiums is scary...

Did an AF quote when i got my GTV bearing in mind the following

45 yr old, no points, 8yrs NCD, advanced driver, civil servant. and the wife as well with similar...2.0 GTV TS

Comprehensive insurance cover + glass + free courtesy car + protected NCD and Green Card

AF £750/yr £400 excess

LV £243/yr £250 excess all the goodies included in protected NCD

Tell me why there is such a difference cos i dont know nor understand this....
 

·
Vendor
Joined
·
45,992 Posts
Tell me why there is such a difference cos i dont know nor understand this....
Its all about the balance of risks, so I'm led to believe. If an insurance company always tries to take a balance of high risk, high premium policies, and low risk, low premium policies. If it needs more high risk drivers, it lowers premiums for them, if it has too many low risk drivers with low premiums, it increases its premiums to them. Sometimes they just don't want your custom, hence the high price.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
343 Posts
I sold a car before and didn't replace it for a few months i phoned to cancel the insurance it was cheaper to pay the last two months at £27.15 a month or £75 to cancel:rolleyes:
 
G

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
I'll add to this rant. I've been with AF a while, I upgraded my policy a few months ago because I had the GTA converted to a 3.8. The increase for the remainder of the year was reasonable I thought. Here we are at renewal time, and a massive hike in the annual premium. How can that be when they only quoted me a few months ago for a revised premium on the 3.8 that now I am subject to a massive hike? Insurance companies really have no concept of customer care, they just try and screw you at renewal time!!!!

So what did I do? I went online to Go Compare of course and found a company specializing in performance cars that was significantly cheaper (and I mean significantly) than AF. Even the AF online quote was cheaper than what they quoted me! Do they think we are stupid? Well, obviously they do, I guess that was a rhetorical question.

Still, at least their lack of customer care has saved me money.

Cheers,

Nigel
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,581 Posts
AF insurance has just done the same to my girlfriend. Absolute daylight robbery. I have 2 cars i will never insure with them and she wont make the mistake of using them again. Such a shame.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,581 Posts
Reading more closely I notice that the original poster changed car type. This is simply changing from a red car to a blue one. Same other than that. So af charge 175 quid more to insure a blue car than a red one. Joke.
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts
Top