Alfa Romeo Forum banner

1 - 20 of 29 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
I know there's been some discussion on here about how to identy the 170bhp GTs, whihc seems to come down to:

  • Can't go by the Cloverleaf badges
  • Sport Button is a guarantee of 170

...but even then, I've seen people posting that they have the sport button on a car that claims to only be 150. And as soon as I've had a look around Autotrader, I've found this, which claims to have a sports button but only be 150 (also says "Possibly has the Q2 Limited Slip Diff but cant 100% confirm"!?). I presume the little red fella by the handbrake in this pic from that ad is the sport button, so we know that part is correct?

Is there any other more definitive way of knowing the power output? Registration based searches don't seem to say - can you get it for definite from the VIN? Or if I see a car in the flesh, is there anything visible under the bonnet that would tell me (same for the Q2, actually, given vague stuff like the above!)?

The other question is wheterh there was another 170 version, other than the Cloverleaf Q2? The gerneal consensus seems to be no, and that agrees with Parkers, but I've seen other mentions of a "Special Edition", whihc could partly explain the advertisedr one I linked to. Anybody know of such a beast?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 · (Edited)
Another question that's occurred to me while looking at GTs on autotrader...

It looks like those without the Sport button have the same panel in place, but without the red button (eg this photo).

I'm guessing that this is just a plastic blank with no actual buttons on it, or is there something else there?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Those buttons are usually ASR and fuel filler cap. I'm guessing the sport button replaces the ASR button
Ah, right - and those two are both black, right?

So does the Q2 system mean that there's no need to be able to turn off the ASR, or is there a different buttong?

I'm slightly amused by the placing of something as mundane as the filler cap there... visions of reaching down for that extra throttle response and accidentally popping it open!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
To be honest, the more I look at GTs on Autotrader, the more puzzled I am. There a several Cloverleafs on there which have the red button, but are listed as 150 and no mention of Q2... much like Dinky's question here.

So either there are "rogue" red buttons out there (might people just be switching over the ASR button for a red one? Seems unlikely en masse!) or loads of people don't know what car they're selling!

And to deepen the mystery further, here's something else I found... According to this website, which seems to have realistic numbers for most models of cars, there were only ever 2 Cloverleaf Q2s and 2 Special Edition Q2s registered.
So I'm wondering if there was some general ****-up with the registration of these Q2s, and they all got recorded as standard 150s?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
33,643 Posts
I know there's been some discussion on here about how to identy the 170bhp GTs, whihc seems to come down to:

  • Can't go by the Cloverleaf badges
  • Sport Button is a guarantee of 170

...but even then, I've seen people posting that they have the sport button on a car that claims to only be 150. And as soon as I've had a look around Autotrader, I've found this, which claims to have a sports button but only be 150 (also says "Possibly has the Q2 Limited Slip Diff but cant 100% confirm"!?). I presume the little red fella by the handbrake in this pic from that ad is the sport button, so we know that part is correct?
That's correct, the red button on the right is the sport button. The one on the right is a black blank (I've just been out and checked).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
207 Posts
Hi I have a 2010 cloverleaf gt . V5 says 150 bhp , it has the sport button and no badges or I.D stickers. I took my gt to my local performance garage and they clocked it at 168 bhp. A trip to my local Alfa dealer and a chat to a mechanic confirms my car is a 170 SE. Seems that at the end of the production run some gt,s got the SE spec but are registerd as 150 .ASR button / filler release is by the drivers air vent ( replaces the headlight adjustment as SE has xenons ) SE only came in red and white. Mechanic also said no 150 had sport button . Hope that helps.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,381 Posts
here (GT Special Edition 2010 White Looks Lovely)

That is the very car I purchased, other than the sticker on the drivers 'B' pillar there is nothing to indicate it as 170bhp.

So I would suggest that you look at the sticker for yourself or get the seller to send a photo of the sticker to confirm whether 150 or 170bhp.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
Hi I have a 2010 cloverleaf gt . V5 says 150 bhp , it has the sport button and no badges or I.D stickers. I took my gt to my local performance garage and they clocked it at 168 bhp. A trip to my local Alfa dealer and a chat to a mechanic confirms my car is a 170 SE. Seems that at the end of the production run some gt,s got the SE spec but are registerd as 150 .ASR button / filler release is by the drivers air vent ( replaces the headlight adjustment as SE has xenons ) SE only came in red and white. Mechanic also said no 150 had sport button . Hope that helps.
Nice one Ricko, clears a lot up.

Crazy how many people seem to be unknowingly selling 170s as 150s, given the supply v demand for 170s.

Potentially also handy for insurance, I guess!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,222 Posts
Oh now I'm (more) confused... where's the fuel cap (as per Jiberson's post)?
Dan your over complicating the situation. The red sport button means its a 170 plain and simple. The 170's came from the factory with clover triangle badges under the front side indicators and nothing else. Although mine had a q2 badge too. But that was rare. You will also if it has not been removed have a silver "cloverleaf 170 sticker in the inner drivers door aperture near the lock striker.

Also as you mentioned it, our 170 pushbutton fuel cap release button is to the right of the steering wheel on a small panel. Although believe it or not some 150's came with it placed here.

The 150 has a single clover leaf emblem on the boot next to the GT badge. And instead of the sport button has a lovely "GT cloverleaf" inner script near the coin tray in the centre console. The blackine's came with a blackline script.

The SE cloverleafs which came later on in the models life did not have clover badges on the body. But these were always later cars.

You are correct in saying you see 170's advertised as 150's. Dealers do not know what they have. When they come in as part exchanges. Which is in the public's favour.

Hope this helps.
Damien.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
Dan your over complicating the situation. The red sport button means its a 170 plain and simple. The 170's came from the factory with clover triangle badges under the front side indicators and nothing else...
The 150 has a single clover leaf emblem on the boot next to the GT badge.
From what I've read on here and seen in listings though, you can't rely on the badges at all, as plenty have additional or missing badges.
I've seen examples with all three badges, and others that were clearly 150s (no red button) but had only the side ones.

The sticker in the door sounds pretty reliable (who's going to bother get one of them post-market!).
Could lead to some odd phone calls to dealers... "yeah, I'm interested, but could you just send me a photo of the inside of the door frame?"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
33,643 Posts
... do people really pay a premium for a few extra ponies and a fancy dif on a car that's essentially a luxurious cruiser, not a nimble sports car...?
Yes.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
33,643 Posts
Speaking from experience I'm assuming Roswell :D
I didn't consider the lesser 150 model so I can't compare.

I remember once I decided I wanted a GT it had to be the most exclusive one available within my price range, hence...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
283 Posts
I went through a similar phase when gearing up for my GT purchase but decided it didn't matter on a a diesel daily drive, especially as outwardly they're identical.

Almost bought an older busso GT but two cars in the garage returning 20 mpg might have got expensive!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
All this cafuffle over 20bhp on a derv! :cheese:

The GT Cloverleaf is a beauty in any form, but do people really pay a premium for a few extra ponies and a fancy dif on a car that's essentially a luxurious cruiser, not a nimble sports car...?
Speaking personally, I'd maybe a small premium for a car that's just a little bit more of a nimble sports car, but probably not the premium you could expect to be charged.
But if people are selling them for the same price, as they don't even realise they're any different, then yes, I'll certainly take the 20 extra and the dif.
 
1 - 20 of 29 Posts
Top