Re: someone reversed into my girls gtv (UPDATED WITH PICS)
Oh, I didn't see the bumper as well, although that looks more superficial than the other damage. Get at least 2-3 quotes. Try an independant Alfa dealer who may be able to recommend someone.
When someone dented my wing and door 2 yrs ago it only cost me £410. I did it privately as my excess was £400 so it wasn't worth it. But I should think around £800-1000 now. But not £1500 as you say unless they are ripping you off in your area. If it's that much I'd use insurance - especially as the other person has admitted responsibility.