Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Currently UK (AT & AUS)
County: Central London
I just had this dilemma, having just picked up my coupe on Saturday.
Drive both and see what you like better.
I like the look of the spider more than the coupe, but being noticeably heavier you can feel the difference when driving (well I can quite easily, I can even feel a large difference when there is a passenger in the car).
If you are buying it for the spiders sake, then yes, if you are buying it for fast cornered country roads, the occasional track day, having something that is unbelievably light and driver focused, then stick with the coupe.
Just my 2cents