Originally Posted by Pud237
Isn't it actually the "total area under the torque curve"/tonne that is most important?

No
..unless you multiply torque by a constant times the rpm.
..which equals power
What matters in the total area under the power curve (time the other dimension) for the rev ranges from redline down to the start point for the next gear.
Basically all that matters is the rate of work that the engine can do..
If you can imagine an engine hooked up to a water pump and pumping water into a big tank..
A 2.4 diesel engine might be able to push out some big gobs of water 4 thousand times a second, a lower torque petrol engine would probably push out smaller amounts of water 7 or 8 thousand times a second but once it pushes out more water over the same time interval its a faster engine.
..and probably in a lighter, better-balanced car to boot
Conceptually It would be the total amount of water pumped that determines how fast the engine would accelerate you over a given time interval.
This is purely determined by power.
Torque Figures are completly irrelevent if you dont consider how many times a second it can be transmitted (i.e. power).
A tractor can have several thousand Nm of torque , but it cant rev very high so has measly power
Then you would worry about the weight, aerodymanics etc to get power/weight etc.
Sure though torque matters for wrong gear acceleration, okay, okay flexability if you must
