Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: I would rather not say
I had a similar problem where the driver side window just dropped in the door and would click if I tried to raise it...
The dealership said the motor was gone or something to that effect and that I needed a new arm/motor....
2 things to keep in mind here
1) new arms are smaller/different shape than om - lots of threads on this, requires an extra mounting hole to be drilled if memory serves me
2) getting the window to set properly in terms of stopping position is diificult (as with all non-framed doors)
Ever since the repair, the door "catches" everytime I open it from the inside and jolts a bit.
Long story short, I would try to find a 2nd hand part, potentially fewer problems and I believe it is the same part number regardless of year - must be one in the local junkyard...
hope this helps and good luck!